Property Settlement Lawyers - Mornington Peninsula & Melbourne
Property division can become complex fast. Our property settlement lawyers support you in securing what’s fair. Book a consultation today.
Work with our highly experienced Mornington Peninsula property settlement lawyers
Our property settlement lawyers understand that managing property division with your former partner after a separation or divorce can be a complex and emotionally challenging process.
Our team specialise in providing clear, compassionate, and expert legal guidance to ensure that your property settlement is handled with care and precision. Serving the Mornington Peninsula and surrounding suburbs, our experienced family law team is here to protect your rights and help you achieve a fair outcome.
Personalised advice & comprehensive support
When it comes to property settlements and financial matters, you need more than just legal expertise. You need a trusted advocate who prioritises your best interests. At Eliza Legal, we offer practical solutions and clear guidance, helping you address property divisions with confidence, with a focus on ensuring a just and equitable outcome.
Whether you need early advice or assistance to resolve complex property disputes, we’ll work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for you and your future.
How we can assist:
- Our property settlement services
- Meet Clare Fleming, your property settlement lawyer
- The four-step settlement process
- Mornington Peninsula property values
- Who keeps the family home?
- Superannuation in your settlement
- Complex and high-value asset pools
- Client story: a hidden asset pool
- Property settlement FAQs
Our Melbourne & Mornington Peninsula Property Settlement Services
Property Settlement Advice
Property Negotiations
Complex Property Structures
Business & Trust Divisions
Meet your local property settlement lawyer, Clare Fleming
Clare Fleming (nee Compaan) is Eliza Legal’s Managing Director and Principal Lawyer, and a Mornington Peninsula local. With a deep understanding of the many practical and emotional factors that can influence property settlements, Clare works closely with her clients to ensure they can make informed choices about their future.
She is passionate about supporting clients with limited financial knowledge after a relationship ends, as well as those facing highly complex financial structures, hidden assets or managing co-occurring challenges such as coercive control.
Clare’s practical, compassionate and solutions-focused approach ensures that those she works with have a clear understanding of their options and entitlements, and are able to move forward to a secure future.

Understanding the four-step process courts use for property settlement
Most people don’t realise that asset division when a relationship ends isn’t straightforward and doesn’t have a set default amount. It’s assessed in line with considerations set out in section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975 for married couples, and section 90SM for eligible de facto couples.
1. Identify and value the asset pool
The first step is to identify what each person owns and owes together and separately. This can include the family home, property, savings, investments, super and any other valuables, as well as debts and liabilities. This establishes the value of the asset pool.
2. Assess financial and non-financial contributions
The next step is to look at what each person has contributed during the relationship. This includes income, debts and assets that each party has brought into the relationship and wealth or debt that has been built during the relationship. It also includes things like care of children, supporting a family business, looking after the home and any gifts from family over that time.
3. Assess the current and future needs of each person
There are lots of things that can affect someone’s ability to earn, including the care of children, age and health, income and earning capacity, financial resources, housing needs and the impact of the relationship breakdown on each person’s circumstances. Since the family law property reforms came in during June 2025, the court must also consider the economic impact of family violence, under section 79(5)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), when relevant.
4. Check the result is just and equitable
Whether your property settlement is organised by lawyers or in court, the final part of the assessment is to ensure it’s just and equitable, accounting for both partners’ contributions and ongoing needs.
If your settlement details are filed as Consent Orders in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, or if your matter is decided in court, the Registrar or Judge needs to ensure the agreement is just and equitable before making it. Most property matters don’t reach court and finalise within a year.
How Mornington Peninsula property values shape your settlement
In local areas across the Mornington Peninsula, the family home can make up a very substantial part of the property pool. In Mount Eliza, the median house price reached $1.8 million in the September 2026 quarter, so even a relatively small movement in the value of the home can change the settlement by tens, or hundreds, of thousands of dollars.
People often don’t think about how much difference a valuation date can make. In 2025, Domain reported a fall of 23.9% in house prices in Sorrento over a single year, while McCrae was one of few areas recording growth, up 7.8% over the same period. Averaged data won’t mean your home has moved by the same percentage, but it’s still important to consider how significantly a property valuation can move in a very short time, and how that could affect the outcome of your property settlement.
Who gets the house? Will either of us be able to keep the family home?
The family home is often one of the most emotional parts of property settlement, especially if you are raising children together. A big question during settlement is often “can either of us keep the family home?”, which often depends on more than who wants to stay.
When considering this question, it is important to understand not only the property’s current market value, but how much equity is left after the mortgage and other liabilities secured against it. This is the amount assessed during settlement.
If one person is keeping the home, you need to consider how the other person’s interest will be accounted for, such as cash payments, other assets or superannuation. Most importantly, it’s necessary to consider whether the person keeping the home can afford the ongoing costs on their own, including the mortgage, rates, insurance and maintenance.
In some settlements, separating parties may agree to retain the property for a period of time, for example, one person stays with the children and the property is sold or decided at a later date. This can provide stability for children of the relationship, but it means both parties remain connected financially during separation, which isn’t ideal for some couples parting ways. Any agreement of this type needs to clearly document mortgage, expenses, use of the property and a timeline for an eventual sale.
I look at the property settlement as a whole, including the value of the home, other assets and liabilities, what has happened since separation and what each person is realistically trying to achieve. If keeping the family home is important to you, I will look at whether that is financially and legally achievable rather than treating the house as simply another figure in the asset pool.
Clare Fleming, Managing Director & Principal Lawyer
Superannuation and your settlement
In Australia, superannuation now makes up around a quarter of all household wealth, although this figure can vary dramatically between individuals, and between partners in a relationship. Superannuation is counted in the property pool during divorce and separation, and can make up a substantial amount of the settlement in many cases. It’s common for super balances to significantly differ in relationships, especially when one person is a higher earner, or one has spent time as a stay-at-home parent.
In 2023-24, ATO figures put the average superannuation balance for men at $202,644, and for women at $164,206, with median figures sitting at $71,914 and $57,688 respectively. Splitting super can have a considerable impact on retirement lifestyle, especially when a couple is nearing retirement age, or have invested in an SMSF, and careful consideration is required to ensure outcomes that best support later years during property settlement. In some cases, a transfer of superannuation interests may be enough to balance out each party’s ongoing needs. In other cases, a split of cash, assets and superannuation will be more suitable.
Complex and high-value asset pools
Property settlement can become more complicated when a relationship involves multiple properties, holiday homes, family trusts or business interests. Across the Mornington Peninsula, these assets can raise important questions about valuation, ownership, control and potential capital gains tax implications.
Eliza Legal helps clients through complex property settlements, looking beyond the family home to understand the broader asset pool and the financial interests involved. We can help you identify the issues that may affect your settlement, understand your options and work towards a resolution that reflects your circumstances. Whether your financial arrangements are straightforward or involve substantial assets and business structures, we provide considered advice tailored to your situation.
Local support for the Mt Eliza community
With its village atmosphere, coastal walks and relaxed Peninsula lifestyle, Mt Eliza is a wonderful place to call home. But when a relationship breaks down, even familiar surroundings can feel very different. Separation brings personal and practical challenges, and knowing where to turn for legal advice can make a difference.
At Eliza Legal, we work with individuals and families across the Mornington Peninsula, providing advice and personal support through difficult family law matters, from both our Mt Eliza and Mordialloc offices. Whether you need help with divorce, parenting arrangements, property settlements, superannuation or family violence, we’ll take the time to understand your circumstances and help you work out the next steps. Our focus is on finding practical legal solutions that reflect your priorities and help you move forward.

Photo: "Moondah Beach Mount Eliza" by Mornington2, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.

Client journey: uncovering a hidden asset pool
In family property settlements, assets are sometimes hidden to tilt the outcome, and sometimes one person simply never had sight of the family finances. Either way, the full picture has to be established before a fair settlement can be negotiated.
Eliza Legal recently acted for a woman separating from her husband with almost no knowledge of the family’s finances: no access to records, no idea which accounts existed, and no funds of her own to draw on.
How we helped
We made detailed enquiries into the parties’ financial interests and uncovered a substantial property portfolio, business interests and a multimillion-dollar asset pool our client had not known about. With full disclosure in hand, we represented her at lawyer-assisted mediation and negotiated an outcome without a final court hearing.
The outcome
The matter settled at mediation and was formalised through consent orders. Most of the assets were sold and our client received a substantial cash payment after tax and costs.
You do not need to know what assets exist before seeking advice. A skilled family lawyer can make the enquiries to establish what is in the pool.
Why clients choose Eliza Legal
Clear advice delivered with compassion
Client-Centred Approach
At Eliza Legal, you are not just another case. We treat every client with the respect, dignity, and attention they deserve, taking the time to understand your concerns and what matters most to you.
Expertise in Family Law
With extensive family law experience, we can guide you through divorce, child custody, property settlements and other family law matters, providing clear advice at each stage.
Empathy and Understanding
We believe in practising law with a heart. We approach every matter with compassion and care, offering practical support and considered guidance throughout the legal process.
Local Focus
Based in Mount Eliza, on the Mornington Peninsula, we are deeply rooted in the local community. We serve clients from Melbourne to the Mornington Peninsula and beyond. We consult with clients in person in our Mt Eliza office, or via video conference.
Our Process
What happens next?
Step 1. Free Discovery Call
In this brief 20-minute meeting, we’ll outline your next steps and explain how our lawyers can assist with your property or financial matters. Please note that detailed legal advice will not be provided during this session.
Step 2. In-Depth Consultation
For more comprehensive advice, book a 90-minute consultation with one of our experienced family lawyers. For just $495 (1.5 hours), you’ll receive tailored advice specific to your financial or property concerns.
Step 3. Engagement & Outcome
Once we have a clear strategy, we’ll continue with ongoing support to implement a personalised plan, working together to secure the best possible property settlement or financial outcome for you.
Hear from the people we’ve helped
Eliza Legal were highly professional, knowledgeable and well prepared to support me. Living through a separation with so much uncertainty has been incredibly difficult. Knowing that I could fully trust the team at Eliza Legal made a difficult process 'doable'. I am so grateful to Jessica and Clare for their compassion, knowledge and expertise.
Clare is such a wonderful, caring and understanding solicitor. She really understands family law and is extremely passionate about what she does.
Through the whole process Clare was reassuring, caring and really helped put my mind at ease during such a hard time. She treats her clients with real kindness and understanding making a difficult time so much easier. I couldn’t recommend her highly enough.
Clare and the team from Eliza Legal have been an incredible help to me. To what at the time was a very stressful period and they managed to ease some of that stress by helping me every step of the way through my separation.
Clare provides an itemised listing of all expenses and goes about matters in a way that put her clients first and ensures to not put on any unnecessary costs. With her friendly personality, she is very approachable and makes her clients feel very comfortable. Very appreciative of her and her teams services and highly recommend.
Property Settlement FAQs
Property settlement involves dividing assets, liabilities, and financial resources between separating couples. This process includes everything from the family home, investment properties, and savings in bank accounts to superannuation (including self-managed superannuation funds) and debts.
At Eliza Legal, we understand that every property settlement is unique, and our goal is to tailor our approach to suit your specific circumstances. We have a deep understanding of the Family Law Act 1975, and will ensure that any proposed property settlement is a just and equitable division.
What are the key factors that determine property settlement outcomes?
A fair settlement considers various factors, such as each party's contributions (financial and non-financial), the length of the relationship, future needs and other relevant circumstances.
- Asset Pool Valuation: Accurate valuation of all property assets, including real estate, vehicles, and personal belongings.
- Financial Contributions: Consideration of each party's financial and non-financial contributions throughout the relationship.
- Future Needs: Assessment of each party's future financial needs, including earning capacity and care of dependents.
Independent legal advice should be sought to ensure that your particular circumstances are well represented so that you can reach a fair property settlement.
A fair settlement considers various factors, such as each party's contributions (financial and non-financial), the length of the relationship, future needs and other relevant circumstances.
- Asset Pool Valuation: Accurate valuation of all property assets, including real estate, vehicles, and personal belongings.
- Financial Contributions: Consideration of each party's financial and non-financial contributions throughout the relationship.
- Future Needs: Assessment of each party's future financial needs, including earning capacity and care of dependents.
Independent legal advice should be sought to ensure that your particular circumstances are well represented so that you can reach a fair property settlement.
Under the Family Law Act 1975, you must apply for a property settlement within 12 months of divorce (Section 44) being finalised. For de facto couples, the application period is 2 years from the date of separation (Section 90SB). Failing to apply within these timeframes may prevent you from making a claim. It’s advisable to seek legal advice early to understand the steps involved in dividing financial assets with your ex-partner.
Property entitlements for divorce and de facto relationship breakdowns are similar under Australian law but with different time limits for claims. In addition to the time limits, proving the existence of a de facto relationship can sometimes be more challenging compared to a marriage. Under section 90SB of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), de facto couples must demonstrate a genuine domestic relationship, which involves factors such as shared finances, living arrangements, and the duration of the relationship. This can complicate property claims if evidence is insufficient.
A property settlement can be finalised through a private agreement, a family law financial agreement or a consent order. A consent order is a legally binding document approved by the court, while a financial agreement is an arrangement between parties that can also be recognised by the court if it meets legal requirements. Privately organised financial settlements can work for some people, but it is highly advisable to seek legal advice from a specialist family lawyer to ensure the arrangement is fair and enforceable. Get in touch with our Mornington Peninsula property settlement lawyers for a chat about how we can help.
A consent order is a legal document approved by the Federal Circuit & Family Court of Australia that outlines the terms of a property settlement or financial arrangement. Once the court approves it, it is legally binding, ensuring both parties are legally obligated to comply with the agreed terms. Parenting matters can also be formalised with consent orders.
A financial agreement is a legally binding contract between two parties that sets out the division of assets and liabilities in the event of a relationship breakdown. It can be made before, during, or after a relationship and requires independent legal advice for validity.
Going to court is often not necessary to finalise property matters. Many couples settle through negotiation or mediation and formalise their agreement with a consent order or financial agreement. However, if a settlement cannot be reached, the family court may be required to decide on property division.
Full and frank disclosure means both parties must provide complete and honest information about their financial circumstances, including assets, liabilities, income, and any hidden financial interests. This ensures a fair division of property and is critical for a legally binding agreement.
At Eliza Legal, our property settlement services are designed to be comprehensive and client-focused. We work closely with you to understand your needs and priorities, guiding you through each step of the settlement process.
Our Property Settlement Process:
- Initial Consultation: We begin with a thorough 90-minute consultation to understand your situation and goals and provide you with preliminary advice.
- Asset Identification and Valuation: We help identify and accurately value all assets and liabilities.
- Negotiation: Our team negotiates on your behalf to reach a fair and equitable settlement, avoiding court where possible.
- Court Representation: If negotiations fail, we provide strong representation in court to protect your interests.
You can reach an agreement without lawyers, but legal advice can help you understand your entitlements and avoid overlooking assets, debts or future risks. A lawyer can also help formalise your agreement so it is legally binding.
Property is not automatically divided equally. The court considers the parties’ financial and non-financial contributions, their current and future circumstances and whether the proposed division is just and equitable. This applies whether you reach an agreement or ask the court to decide.
Yes. Superannuation is treated as property and can be considered as part of the overall asset pool. It may be split between former partners through a superannuation agreement or court orders, although a split is not required in every settlement.
Yes. One person may keep the family home as part of the property settlement, usually by transferring ownership and refinancing the mortgage where necessary. Its value and any associated debt are considered alongside the other assets and liabilities.
For married couples, court proceedings generally need to begin within 12 months after a divorce takes effect. For de facto couples, the usual limit is two years from separation. Different arrangements may be possible by agreement, and extensions can be granted in some circumstances.
Legal costs depend on the complexity of your financial circumstances and whether you can reach an agreement. Eliza Legal offers a complimentary 20-minute consultation to discuss your situation and understand how the firm may be able to help.
Both can formalise a property settlement. Consent orders are made by the court after reviewing the proposed agreement. A binding financial agreement is a private legal agreement subject to strict requirements, including independent legal advice for each party.
De facto couples can access the family law property settlement framework, but eligibility requirements apply. These include factors such as the relationship's duration, having a child together or making substantial contributions. Different time limits also apply to court applications.
Connect with the team at Eliza Legal
Contact our expert property settlement lawyers in the Mornington Peninsula to discover how we can help you resolve your family law matter. We’ll work with you to reach a fair financial outcome, so you can move forward with confidence.

